Tag Archives: Green Hand Book

Starmind – Dave Van Arnam (1969)

When selecting my novel, I was looking for something unique and different that I felt that a lot of sf stories tended to miss. I didn’t want your typical action-adventure soap opera that was characteristic of this genre — my mind tends to like stories that deal with issues of a more philosophical and existential nature. While lots of science fiction features voyages outward, searching for answers within the infinite cosmos, I believe that searching within one’s “inner space” is a much more productive and useful endeavor. The reason I chose Starmind was because of the tagline “What ships can be launched on the far seas of the mind?” because it speaks to the potential within one’s internal universe, and alludes to the immense power that is contained within each and every one of us, which is a topic that I personally find fascinating.

Starmind essentially tells the story of three characters —  Jailyn Rost, a Martian princess with a rich family; Joe Winslow, an expert on the topic of multi-wave research and engineering, and Benjy Tyler, a 19-year old boy with an intellectual disability. Each of them were coincidently involved in three separate freak accidents, such that only one half of Jailyn’s brain, one half of Joe’s brain, and Benjy’s body were viable. As such, they were subject to the first double brain transplant in their history, and the three of them — as Benjy’s midbrain and cerebellum remained, so he was present to some degree — learned to coexist in one body and seek out their purpose in life, which culminates in them learning to manipulate the “multi-wave” using the power of their combined minds to discover faster-than-light interstellar travel.

While the premise of this novel may lead one to believe that this may be considered soft science fiction, as it deals with issues of the mind and “inner space”, I would place this book firmly in the category of hard sf. This is because it describes the various processes and happenings within the story with an extreme verbosity, chock full of technical jargon and many novums, so much so that I feel that it detracts from the original point of novel, serving only as a boring and annoying digression.

That being said, the highlight of this novel is observing the three personalities interacting with each other and learning to coexist. Here, Van Arnam does an excellent job of crafting vibrant characters that the reader can learn to love and root for. Everything else in my opinion could be ignored, as there were several sections of the novel that described various phenomena in extreme detail for seemingly no reason, which I found particularly frustrating. Additionally, the theme of sexuality appears over and over through this novel, sometimes in ways that are uncomfortable, and do not add much value to the story.

Overall while the premise of this book is very exciting and interesting, its execution leaves a bit to be desired. Some sections of the book can be difficult to get through, as the storytelling can get long-winded and uninteresting. It does pick up toward the middle of the story, however the final third of the book is a little difficult to understand. As a result I would only really recommend this book if you have spare time to kill and the idea of seeing how three minds interact in one body is of particular interest to you. Otherwise you most likely will not enjoy it much.

Van Arnam, Dave. Starmind. Ballantine Books, June 1969.

(Narmer Bazile)

Ball Lightning by Cixin Liu

I chose Ball Lightning for three reasons, only one of which is actually a fair assessment of the book. Reason 1 was that the cover was pretty. Reason 2 (the good one) was that I had heard good things about the author, Cixin Liu, from friends in the past. Reason 3 (my personal favorite and the most convincing) was that the reviewer featured on the cover was none other than Barack Obama, which was unexpected enough that I decided I needed to read it for the memes if nothing else.  

The book follows Chen, a man whose parents were killed by ball lightning in his youth. This event sparked a lifelong obsession with the phenomenon, leading him down dangerous paths and into revolutionary knowledge. I would classify this novel as definitively hard SF, as it delves into a real life phenomenon and brings in a lot of actual science. While I am usually more of a fan of soft SF, the science here was one of my favorite aspects of the story. I really appreciated the realism that it granted a story that is clearly speculative fiction, and the details about research funding felt pretty realistic and grounded the story well. 

One thing that frustrates me about this novel is its portrayal of female characters. All of the female characters feel like they are there fully to tell us something about the male characters. There was one scene with a female character whose only character trait was ‘desirable’ who was flirting with Chen, who ignored her and felt powerful for it. Chen is only interested in Lin Yun, his love interest, because she has not like other girls energy. I did not finish the entire novel, so I cannot say for sure whether this pattern held, but it was very annoying to me as a female reader. 

I think I would recommend this book, mainly because I think it was really well researched and Liu has a great command of suspense. While I had my issues with the novel, I still found myself wanting to know what happened next and invested in the plot. 

 

A note: The novel was originally published in Chinese in 2005, but the English translation was published in 2018.

Works Cited

Liu, Cixin. Ball Lightning. Translated by Joel Martinsen, Tor Books, 2018.

Camp Concentration (1968): A Review

Camp Concentration (1968) by American author Thomas Disch first caught my eye with its title, which caused my Jew-dar to go off. Could this be an offensive Sci-Fi take on a Holocaust narrative?, I wondered, with mild horror. The cover art and the non-Jewish sounding name of the author seemed to suggest, “Maybe.” I figured it was my duty as a Jew to find out. After skimming the first few pages, I came to the conclusion that the book was not in fact a science fiction interpretation of the Holocaust, but a story vaguely about the Vietnam War—-the title simply appeared to be a play on words. My interest nevertheless piqued, I bought the book.

Camp Concentration is written as a series of diary entries from the pen of a man named Louis Sacchetti, who has been imprisoned in a mysterious military camp for being a conscientious objector to an unnamed conflict (implied to be the Vietnam War). Sacchetti, a writer, was specially selected for his intelligence, which the camp directors seek to maximize as part of an experimental program. He is one of several subjects who is injected with a type of syphilis that is meant to enhance mental strength, but also causes deterioration of the physical form. The novel tracks Sacchetti’s strange experiences with fellow prisoners and his gradual devolution into insanity. Explored in Camp Concentration  are themes of future wars, contagion, and the mad scientist. I would classify the book as soft science fiction, as it is focused more on the psychology of its characters (“inner space”) than the technology behind the camp’s experiments. 

I didn’t love this book, but Samuel Delaney and Ursula K. LeGuin did, at least according to the quotes featured on the book’s jacket, so maybe I just don’t have taste. I found the book to be a bit tedious—the flowery language and abundant esoteric references are no doubt purposeful given that the narrator is supposed to be a tortured writer, but they make for difficult reading. Camp Concentration is also alarmingly racist at times—one of the main characters, who is black, is at multiple points given a minstrel-like description, for example. Overall, I would say that this book doesn’t merit the description of “Artful and brilliant,” which one of the cover quotes confers to it. I would not recommend it. 

I honestly had a better time reading about the author, Thomas Disch, then I did reading this book. One of my favorite things that I learned was that Disch had a weird feud with Philip K. Dick, who was Disch’s friend before he wrote a paranoid letter to the FBI that slandered Disch and implied that there were seditious coded messages in Camp Concentration. In his last novel, The Word of God, Disch got back at Dick with a story in which Dick is in Hell suffering from writer’s block and makes a Devil’s Bargain to go back in time so he can write again. Dick winds up killing Disch’s dad and changing history so that Hitler wins World War II. Many years following the publishing of The Word of God, Disch also wrote a blog post in which, referring to Dick, he says, “May he rot in hell, and may his royalties corrupt his heirs to the seventh generation” (“Thomas Disch”). Damn.

Bibliography:

Disch, Thomas. Camp Concentration. 1968. Avon Books, 1971.

“Thomas M. Disch.” Wikipedia, 30 Apr. 2022. Wikipedia, https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Thomas_M._Disch&oldid=1085371257.