Protecting the Black Experience and Cultural Appropriation

The narrator notes how “before the internet, before the hip-hop, the spoken-word poetry, the Kara Walker silhouettes” white people did not care what black people did (230). The black experience “used to come with lots of bullshit, but at least there was fucking privacy” (230). The narrator states how fashion and slang “didn’t cross over until years after the fact” (230). I think Beatty includes this rant to speak on the cultural appropriation of black culture. It is not something that is obvious to many people and still is a difficult concept to grasp for many people who don’t come from communities of color. I think this form of isolation that the narrator is nostalgic about is also a form of segregation. In order to protect black culture, it had to be unknown to white society and private. It is troubling to me where the line between admiration for black culture and exploitation of it exists. I thought the reference to Kara Walker was also confusing because I saw her as an artist trying to express black and white conceptions of race, gender, sexuality, violence and sexuality. Is breaking into previously white dominated areas like art museums and collections another way you lose your privacy as a black person? Is this the cost of being successful in a white society?  Many things from fashion, dance and music are rooted in black communities but are making it to the mainstream more and more each day. The lack of privacy Beatty notes makes the black experience available to more people that don’t really care to know about it but instead, want to play a role or explore a new fashion trend. I’m interested on what you guys think about this.  

One thought on “Protecting the Black Experience and Cultural Appropriation

  1. Praise Hall

    I completely agree. I had a similar sentiment myself. In particular at the end of the spill on pg. 230, Hominy says, “Massa, no one gives a fuck about the hood until they give a fuck (230).” Beatty ends the discussion of black cultural appropriation with this quote. In so many ways I believe it captures the essence of what Beatty is saying. No one care about the culture until they want to or until it is relevant it to them. Simultaneously this passage could also be saying that no one gives a fuck about the hood (culture) until they wanted to screw it over. What do you think?

Leave a Reply