From the first ten sonnets of Shakespeare, it is clear that he is in favor of procreation and believes it to be a disservice to oneself and the world not to do so. However, he moves around on the purpose in doing so. This seems to suggest that there would be many reasons for strongly believing one should procreate. These reasons are generally compatible, but I did find one contradiction. Sonnet 3 encourages procreation for the purpose of self service. Sonnet 3 states that one’s image dies when a person dies, if that person has not procreated. This same sonnet states the beauty of seeing one’s self in the body of a child is an exciting one. These ideas all seem to be in self service. On the other hand, almost every other sonnet states alternative purposes, such as giving the world what it is owed (sonnet 1) or perpetuating beauty. Sonnet 6 even specifically states, “Be not self-willed.” Are the feelings encouraged in sonnet 3 contradictory to the other sonnets of the first 10? Can these reasons for procreation exist in harmony? These thoughts all remind me of the section of the Vendler reading that discusses reading sonnets individually versus as a whole. Reading these sonnets all together give a very different picture of Shakespeare’s beliefs than reading one individually.
History of Sexuality re: Sonnets
I really liked the Foucault reading, more than I expected actually, and reading Marlowe’s sonnet and then Donne and Raleigh’s response, I couldn’t help but think about how it often feels like certain poems “confess” more than others. Marlowe’s sonnet is troubled and ultimately picked apart by Donne and Raleigh. It seems to have more meaning when read side by side with their responses. Re-reading Marlowe’s sonnet after reading all three, it seemed flimsy and almost absurd. There seems to be a certain pleasure, if that’s the word, in seeing the “truth” of the original sonnet unveiled. As Foucault says, “we must ask whether, since the nineteenth century, the scientia sexualis– under the guise of its decent positivism- has not functioned, at least to a certain extent, as an ars erotica” (70). Foucault’s article ultimately made me wonder how poetry is involved in “the production” of truth– this production perhaps requires a dialogue both between poems and within them.
Welcome to the “Renaissance Sexualities” course blog
You are free to use this blog to comment on the readings and to respond to comments by other students. It is visible only to members of the class, and every post is tagged with the author’s name. Please post at least once under each category, and please keep your responses brief and specific.
Enjoy!
