Knowles discusses Barnfield’s defense against claims of the “dangerous and sodomitical implications” in the sonnets in Cynthia (678). In Barnfield’s response, Knowles explains that these “implications are rejected and turned back on the reader” but at the same time, may alert the reader to the sexual implications of his poems (678). Knowles leaves it then somewhat ambiguous as to Barnfield’s ideas with respect to the homoerotic implications of the sonnet. However, I would suggest based on Sonnet XVII that Knowles’ second suggestion may be more accurate. My focus is on the last couplet of this poem, where the speaker says “Oh how can such a body sinne-producing,/Be slow to love, and quick to hate, enduring” (13-14)? This line suggests to me Barnfield’s purposefulness and full awareness in the homoerotic implications of the poem–by calling the actions “sinne-producing” this seems to be referencing relations between men which would have been viewed as sinful. If there was nothing socially questionable about this love, this line would be very out of place.
Self-control and the sonnet
I was struck by how Knowles’ observations on sexuality related to the content and structure of the sonnets from Barnfield’s Cynthia, particularly the relationship between homoerotic relationships and masculinity. The speaker’s fascination with Ganymede reflects the old practice of pederasty as he is obsessed with his subject’s youth and beauty. Though a pederastic relationship usually involves a master-servant-like power imbalance, with the older man holding power over the younger due to age, power, and/or position, here Ganymede seems to hold the power through his ability to refuse the speaker’s advances. As the speaker becomes increasingly desperate in his professions of love, Ganymede inadvertently strips him of his power through Ganymede’s own indifference. The speaker tries to sway Ganymede with the typical masculine act of gift giving (Sonnet XVIII), but because of his blatant declarations of affection, he ends up sacrificing his self-control and thus his semblance of masculinity (Knowles 684). Barnfield’s use of the sonnet plays with this idea of self-control, for though the tight form of the sonnet requires great eloquence and restraint, it enables the speaker to unrestrictedly and immoderately express his romantic and sexual passions.
Richard Barnfield–Color Imagery and Classical References
In reading Richard’s Barnfield’s sonnets for class today, I was struck by his (consistent) use of the same colors, red and white, throughout his poems as well as his classical references, both of which seem to work together in several poems of almost displacing the body of the beloved for this sort of imagery. More specifically, I was struck by how Sonnet IX is reminiscent of a creation myth, in this case the creation of the beloved. In the poem, Diana “pricke her foote against a thorne” and with the stream of bloode she “formes a shape of Snow, / And blends it with this blood,” creating Ganymede. The beloved, thus, seems to exist in this poem and others almost as the product of the Gods and nature–the poem even ends with modifying the name Ganymede with “as all divine.” To me, this way of introducing the beloved seemed detached from physical characteristics of the beloved and step away from the blazon tradition we’ve seen in other poems, yet still manages to celebrate the beloved in a more spiritual manner.
Shakespeare Sonnet #5
Raisa, Austin, and I chose this poem for it is seemingly unique in not directly referencing reproduction. We read the poem through Vendler’s categories of perception and philosophy. The speaker is particularly focused on “summer’s distillation” (9) and and “flower’s distilled” (13), calling to mind perfume. Yet, he seems to use sight and visualization as his main type of perception. He uses strong imagery in lines such as “sap checked with frost” (7) and “liquid prisoner pent in walls of glass” (10). This subtly forces the reader to continue think about physical beauty, even as the poem is ostensibly about essence. Similarly, Shakespeare questions the philosophy of reproduction in this poem by arguing that the poem itself is a way for this man to preserve his beauty, not reproduction. Shakespeare talks a lot in this poem of remembrance vs. forgetting, as well as preserving “substance” (14), and seems to use the poem in order to distill the man’s beauty and essence into 14 lines. Raisa and Austin, all yours!
Shakespeare Sonnet 8, re:Wednesday’s class
Attack from all sides
I was interested by how each of the sonnets seemed to have a its own individual theme, a specific point of attack to convince the reader to reproduce (although in the cases of sonnets 5 & 6, 9 & 10, there were some prolonged attacks over the course of two poems). At first reading, I was particularly struck by words that I usually would not associate with a love poem — such as how in Sonnet 4, all of Shakespeare’s reproductive imagery is measured in monetary terms, or in Sonnet 1, where he uses strong metaphors about (lack of) food/eating — but he still masterfully constructed these “odder” words to suit his message. It was helpful to read Vendler’s article afterwards about how there is something “cryptographic” about a Shakespearean sonnet, particularly how there is “an oddness that catches the eye and begs explanation” (40). Vendler also talked a lot about structure’s importance within the sonnet; I began to wonder if there was any significance about the sonnets’ arrangement as a whole, although Vendler mentioned that the sonnets were probably ordered ad libitum so perhaps this is a stretch. Yet clearly, these sonnets are a set with an overarching purpose; there seems to be a sort of inwards to outwards progression throughout the ten, starting from basic human needs (like food in Sonnet 1, your own image in 2, mother in 3, money in 4) to natural joys (flowers/summer in 5 & 6, the sun in 7, music in 8) then finally ending with family and society in Sonnets 9 & 10. Perhaps Shakespeare did not intend for this arrangement to be this meaningful, but I find these sonnets all the more persuasive because of the way his argument unfolds within the set, slowly drawing in the reader and amplifying the argument; at first, it seems to be about just making sure your own beauty is preserved for yourself, but then, at the end, your choice to reproduce will affect the whole world.
Edmund Spencer 37 & 67
Edmund Spencer’s sonnet 37 and 67 from Amoretti are interesting because they reverse the conventional gender roles often seen in poems like “The Passionate Shepherd to his Love.” In sonnet 37, the speaker mentions that women’s appearance often deceives men because of how well they are presented. One example he includes is the woman’s hair which is wrapped in a net of gold, but he does not know what is hair or what is gold. Her beauty causes him to loose his power in differentiating what is real and what is not. He states, “In which if ever ye entrapped are, Out of her bands ye by no means shall get.” The woman he describes is the one who seduces or does the wooing. Men have the weaker hearts, and are depicted to succumb to the power of women’s beauty. In sonnet 67, Spencer uses the hunting metaphor that we’ve seen in “Whoso List To Hunt” by Wyatt, but he gives the woman or the dear the power. Although he believes he is hunting the dear, he is not successful until the dear returns on her own will. The dear allows him to capture her, which could be interpreted as a man cannot get a woman unless she wants him to. Because the dear makes the decision, it shows that she controls the fate of their relationship. The dear has done the hunting, and she chose him, rather than the opposite.
Dad Jokes
I began reading Shakespeare’s sonnets with Vendler’s thoughts on voice in mind. Vender argues that “the act of the lyric is to offer its reader a script to say” (28). The sonnet becomes inhabited by the reader/speaker, not overheard. How do we interpret Shakespeare’s tone in this set of sonnets encouraging procreation and posterity, then? Throughout reading these ten sonnets, I imagined Shakespeare winking and nudging at a young man, telling him in myriad ways to get on with it and have children. Yet if we are to use the sonnet as a script, who might take on the “I” of these sonnets? A higher force? A father? Vendler states that “if we are to be made to enter the lyric script, that the voice offered for our use be ‘believable’ to us, resembling a ‘real voice’ coming from a ‘real mind’ like our own” (28). Shakespeare achieves this realness. To me, he reads like an overbearing father cracking dad jokes at an indignant son— like saying, if you don’t give me grandkids, “make worms thine heir” (6).
The Value of Simplicity: Undermining the Sonnet from Within
While the stylistic importance of Shakespeare’s sonnets stands without doubt, Samuel Daniel’s Sonnet 46 from Delia offers a somewhat simpler, refreshing take on a generally ornate form. Daniel’s piece serves as a sort of preemptive elegy to his speaker’s beloved, employing more exultation than lamentation, lending it a more optimistic and reverent tone. The speaker spurns the notion of a – in his eyes – dated courtly love, instructing “others [to] sing of knights and paladins” (Daniel 965, 1), and he dismisses words and “agèd accents” that he deems “untimely” (obsolete) (Daniel 965, 2). He simply seeks to sing of his love and her “fair eyes” (Daniel 965, 5), rather than creating an elaborate metaphor to illustrate their beauty. Though Daniel adopts a form of the past in composing a sonnet, he undermines this form from within by updating its language and subject matter to fit the contemporary moment. Like Shakespeare, his speaker does address the march of time as an unstoppable force, but he takes heart in the fact that his words, his “arks” and “trophies” (Daniel 965, 9) will immortalize his beloved – will “fortify [her] name against old age” (Daniel 965, 10) – whatever beauty she may lose in the passing years, and encourages his reader to do the same. The speaker is entirely self-conscious of the simplicity of his words, which he feels might be interpreted as inexperience or lack of talent – “th’error of [his] youth” (Daniel 965, 13) – but these words “show [he] lived and was [her] lover” (Daniel 965, 14), which is all he seeks to show in composing this to her. He does not feel the need to lament their eventual descent into old age, or to aggressively pressure her into procreation before her beauty fades – he just wants to show he loves her. A million overly florid poems could not express true love so clearly, so simply, as this one, and its shift in language also signals a shift toward modernity.
Shakespeare Was a Real Boss
Reading Vendler’s article and then reading Shakespeare’s sonnets, I was struck by exactly how talented Shakespeare was as a sonnet poet. Now, yes this is blindingly obvious, but it comes with further justification. I had never fully appreciated that, as Vendler notes, “Shakespeare comes late in the sonnet tradition, and he is challenged by that very fact to a display of virtuosity, since he is competing against great predecessors” (Vendler 27). That Shakespeare came late in the sonnet tradition is something that I, if I am being honest, never knew. Because, growing up and reading Sonnets in English classes, you assume that the guy basically invented the form. That he was able to take the sonnet and have such an influence that, 400 years later, we are talking about him as the master, is really impressive. Impressive beyond the impressive nature of his poetry, and impressive beyond his list of achievements. It’s impressive because he, before he had first put pen to paper, had to mentally grapple with the fact that he was writing in a form that was 1) on its way out, and 2) already saturated with brilliant poets. I guess what I am saying in this post is that, putting his literary mastery aside, Shakespeare’s mentality is also something to be truly marveled at.
