I really enjoyed Donne’s poem the Ecstasy poem because I think its interesting how Donne argues the importance of physical and spiritual love. He was able to justify his point of view through arguments that were actually persuasive and logical in my opinion. Even though he is notorious for at times going over the limit in what he says, his poem does clearly show how his opinion at the time is very controversial in comparison to the societal consensus on premarital sex being wrong.
Religion & Domination
Mueller talks about the power imbalance in heterosexual couples as shown through the perspectives of the male speakers, and I was interested in how the power differences translate to his religious works like the Holy Sonnets. In relation to God, the male speaker is no longer the dominant figure and instead becomes the subordinate. His subservient position seems more motivated by “fear rather than love of God” (148). Because at the time God was often thought of as a male being, I thought it would be interesting to look at the speaker-God relationship in light of other homosocial/erotic/sexual relationships that involve power dynamics, such as the pederastic master-servant relationship. In Holy Sonnet 14, for example, the speaker—who is, as a Christian, a servant of God—asks for God to “enthrall” (13) and “ravish” (14) him, which has a sexual connotation of domination. Donne’s use of sexual language in a religious context offers a slightly confusing understanding of sexuality and power in relation to Christianity.
Micro/Macro and the Poem
I would argue that the poem itself is the ideal form for Donne to explore the concept between the micro and macro, the general and specific. A poem calls for its readers to pay close attention to an overall global message, but also to individual word choice and its impact upon the poem. In this way, the form of the poem itself reflects one of Donne’s main rhetorical techniques.
A Valediction: Forbidding Mourning
Adrienne Rich, a 20th century American feminist poet, wrote “A Valediction Forbidding Mourning” in 1970. The poem is undoubtedly modeled after John Donne’s poem of the same name; however, Rich ironically parodies Donne’s original work. In both poems, the speakers deal with leaving their lovers and discuss the emotions they feel as they contemplate this separation.
Although both poems are about the experience of being apart from a lover, they take radically different stances on the subject. Donne’s love is so strong and refined that the physical distance will ultimately be meaningless. In contrast, Rich is dealing with a difficult relationship and an impending separation that will last forever.
In Donne’s poem, the speaker argues that being apart from one’s lover is not a reason to mourn, for the love he has for the woman he speaks of is so pure that he knows they will remain connected despite their physical distance from one another. Rich’s poem, in contrast, is far less classically romantic than Donne’s. Though it takes on a similar topic of being separated from a lover, Rich imagines a separation that will last “forever,” unlike Donne’s imagining of an everlasting love. Although in Donne’s poem, the two lovers will presumably reunite at some point, this is not the case in Rich’s poem. She tells the person that she is addressing that she wants them to “see this before she leaves,” and then says “when I talk of taking a trip I mean forever.” This is not a temporary separation, and therefore it doesn’t share the overly romantic tone of Donne’s poem.
Inept with Blogs: Response to Natalie
I noticed that I had left this saved as a draft from last week, so here is my reply to Natalie’s post on misogyny in Elizabethan England.
I certainly felt a little uncomfortable about the disregard of consent in “Hero and Leander,” but I also wondered how much of that is depicting a lack of consent or continuing the theme of women as the seductresses ruining a man’s virtue. Like we’ve seen with the Sirens in The Odyssey or Duessa in The Faerie Queene, women seem to be nothing more than tempting objects meant to thwart the stories’ heroes, making their own feelings and identities, unfortunately, nonexistent.
Autobiographical Writing and “The Flea”
Emily raised a question in class yesterday about whether the variety in Donne’s poems could be looked at from an autobiographical point of view, with the content reflecting his own experiences, feelings, and opinions over time. Donne’s marriage to Anne More was forbidden by her father, and resulted in both being disowned. “The Flea” describes a an affair in which a pregnancy comes before marriage, “A sin, or shame, or loss of maidenhead…And pampered swells with one blood made of two” in the first stanza and “This flea is you and I, and this our marriage bed” in the second. Because Donne mentions a lack of parental approval of their marriage, reflecting his own life experience, it brings into question the additional use of autobiographical experience in the first semester. Like Shakespeare and Anne Hathaway, who got married while she was already pregnant, it would be interesting to see if any evidence of this exists with Donne’s marriage, since their recluse during their marriage may have allowed for this type of secret.
Re: Catholic Sensibility?
Hi Alexandra,
I agree with you that Donne’s poetry has a sort of opulence to it that is reminiscent of Catholicism and its remarkable art. I wonder what to make of the fact that he makes a point to mock it in his poetry. His lovers become saint-like from decidedly unholy acts in “The Canonization”. He directly calls Catholicism a “mis-devotion” and fears that him and his lover will be dug up and brought to the “Bishop” and the “King” after their deaths. Formally, even, Donne continually blows up his central conceits and formal structures as he writes each new poem, essentially rejecting the Catholic emphasis on ritual. I wonder if part of this is an attempt to prove his renunciation of Catholicism as he joins the protestant church. Ultimately, however, it is fascinating just to see how he is able to play with, combine, and subvert so many different conventions (religious, social, literary) all at once.
Connection between “The Funeral” and “The Canonization”
I was interested in the forms of the two poems and the various ways in which they were connected. Formally, they are very similar. “The Funeral” is shorter than “The Canonization,” but their stanzas are set up very similarly as far as length and indentations. They also both seem to be very stern warnings towards others. They have a strong opinion on something, and they are each very direct in getting that point across. Do you think that the form of these poems contributes in any way to the version of a message they are trying to send? This seems to be especially true because none of the other Donne works we have read follow this exact form.
Holy Sonnets-10
Donne personifies death in sonnet 10, which is common, but he claims that death has no real power. Death is inferior to “fate, chance, kings and desperate men.” Drugs (opium) are superior to death because it “makes us sleep as well.”In this instance, Donne takes something that is perceived as macro (death) and makes it micro. Donne mentions that death will die, which seems like he is equating death to humans. But he says death cannot kill him, thus also making humans superior to death. Ironically, this sonnet was published two years after Donne’s death, but we are still reading his work today.
Catholic sensibility?
For my third blog post in a row (yikes), I have a stray thought/question: doesn’t the corporeality and the baroqueness of Donne’s work make him feel like a poet of a rather Catholic sensibility? As opposed to Spenserian sanitized Protestantism. It’s interesting because, as we talked about in class, Donne literally was a Catholic poet until he converted to the Anglican Church. But it seems to me that the Catholicism sticks around in his work. Even in the Holy Sonnets, which are substantially less sexual and bodily than the poems we read for last class, the paradoxes that he plays with and the richness of his ideas+language lend the poems a sort of opulence.
(Plus, the Holy Sonnets sequence play so perfectly into the trope of Catholic guilt. Holy Sonnet VII, IX, etc.)
