Re: Sarah’s post “Impediments to Marriage”

(I posted a response to this a week ago but for some reason I’m not seeing it showing up in my posts so I’m going to try to re-write it to the best of my memory! Sorry to backtrack!!)

Going a little further along in the passage you quoted, I thought there was some interesting language on what happens if someone presents an impediment: “then the Solemnization must be deferred unto such time as the truth to be tried”

My instinct is to read “tried” in the sense of a trial, which is to say that they’re going to adjudicate the “truth”. It’s such a weird turn of phrase to me because it seems as though the truth is linked to the person declaring the impediment — which enough to stop the Solemnization — but then the truth needs to be judged. If it’s the truth, isn’t it just … the truth? Wouldn’t the truth theoretically be the result of the judgment? I’m probably leaning too heavily on the legal-ness at work here (which I know nothing about w/r/t modern day, and so obviously even less w/r/t Renaissance England). It’s also likely that I’m conflating “truth” too much with the impediment, and perhaps they mean it in the broader, more expected sense of the truth of the matter. But still, the “truth” seems to be put into this liminal position of being enough to stop the proceedings, but not enough to be impervious to judgment, which is to say (very weirdly) the true truth.

 

Wit

There’s a really amazing one-act play called Wit by Margaret Edson about a Donne scholar dying of ovarian cancer. It won the Pulitzer prize for Drama in 1999, and was turned into an HBO movie in 2001. Here’s a link to the full movie on YouTube — warning: it’s super super sad.

In Wit, there’s a scene protagonist, Vivian Bearing, recalls an encounter she had with her mentor about the punctuation in the last line of Holy Sonnet 10. The problem is that Vivian wrote a paper using an edition of the poem that was “hysterically” punctuated (“And Death shall be no more; Death, thou shalt die!”, whereas the mentor prefers a poem with much less punctuation (“And death shall be no more, death thou shalt die”). Incidentally, our edition punctuates the line somewhere in between.

If you want to watch the scene, here’s a link to it directly. It starts at roughly 6:50 and goes on for 3 minutes.

I can’t speak to the scholarly validity of the play’s claim, although do I find the interpretation compelling. What I like about this scene is how concretely it illustrates how seemingly minor differences in manuscript, in editions can significantly alter the reading of a poem. We talked about this quite a lot when we were reading Shakespeare’s sonnets, and I’d forgotten about this scene’s existence until I made the mistake of rewatching Wit in the library.

“The Flea”

When reading “The Flea,” I was interested in its seeming transformation of the carpe diem poem. While the theme is similar (encouraging someone to have sex), the style and metaphor used in the poem is so incredibly different. There is nothing pastoral about this poem, rather it is entirely based on the concept of the flea’s ability to suck blood.

Donne’s Complicated Piety

I’m having a little trouble reconciling the heavily implied eroticism of Donne’s poetry with his supposedly unassailable piety. In Izaac Walton’s biography of Donne, Walton makes the poet appear as a sort of bastion of Anglican beliefs and practices – practices that proponents of the Church of England often contrasted with the more “sensual” elements of worship in Catholicism. The Norton biography of Donne also points out that Donne only took his position of leadership at St. Paul’s, which he had been holding off on doing, due to his dire financial circumstances. This reluctance, in combination with the subjects of much of his oeuvre, might lead one to question how much of a model of English protestantism of the period Donne truly was.

Women & The Jacobean Era

Reading the introduction in the Norton, I was curious about how the “entry of Englishwomen into authorship and publication” changed the literary climate. Although the Norton describes specific women authors and their work, I wonder how the fact that women had begun to write changed the artistic culture in this time period as a whole. I also wonder how this new addition contributed to the conflict between new and old, between capitalist and feudal.

Response to Raisa’s point on “innocence”

Hi Raisa,

I thought your point about male “innocence” was interesting; I’ve been finding that the idea of innocence seems to be very multi-layered, such as how Hero is innocent/pure, yet capable of killing men with her denials and having enough sexual knowledge to be a “tease.” Apart from being contradictory, innocence also seems to have several different meanings; I wonder how this idea about a man’s “innocency” in the Book of Common Prayer could be more associated with moral innocence/religious purity vs. sexual innocence, since it seems as if there is an expectation for men to be the more sexually experienced ones in the marriage.

Connection between the Ralegh reading and Donne?

While doing the reading, I was at first surprised by the inclusion of Sir Walter Ralegh’s text from The Discovery of Guiana in a section about Donne. At first glance, they seemed very far apart – Ralegh lived in a different political regime in the 16th century, Donne in the 17th; Ralegh writes in prose about the discovery of El Dorado. This seemed something much more like a fanciful documentary than Donne’s rich verse.

However, when I reached the passage on p.886 about how “Guiana is a country that hath yet her maidenhead, never sacked, turned, nor wrought,” I started perhaps thinking about how Ralegh here also uses explicit sexual metaphors in a new way – in this case, to describe the virginity and rape/pillaging(?) of a new land. I would be interested to know what others thought about the connection between Ralegh’s text here and Donne.

A Valediction: Of Weeping

In reading for class today, I was taken with Donne’s use of metaphor. The way Donne shifts between macrocosm and microcosm is really breathtaking, in moments. I’m drawn especially to the middle stanza of “A Valediction: Of Weeping,” which moves from a round ball that becomes a globe, representing the world, and a tear, representing a person, to then joint tears, to “heaven dissolvéd so.” As in The Bait, and in other contemporary verse, water is a focal point here, as something that can speak to both a grand and a minute scale. Water is something that can “wear,” in bearing the lover’s image, as well as can “overflow/ This world.”

Book of Common Prayer

I think Sarah brought up an interesting point about relating the marriage ceremony to the public/private discussion we were having in class. While reading I also noticed the line, “I require and charge you (as you will answer at the dreadful day of judgement, when the secrets of all hearts shall be disclosed) that if either of you do know any impediment why ye may not be lawfully joined together in matrimony, that ye confess it.” Although not said word for word, this is something that is still said in weddings today. It shows that marriage is not a private event, and that the joining of two people includes the opinions of their communities or families. I think this also reminds me of why people choose to have a ceremony and invite guests in the first place. Many book religions state the importance of having “legal witnesses” in weddings to legitimize the union of two people, and whether or not it is religious, ceremonies are a huge part of wedding culture today, thus making it more public than private.

Hero and Leander

My group and I didn’t get to share some of our ideas about Hero, but we mostly talked about her double nature and how contradictory it was. Her clothes were described as being made of “lawn.” In the footnotes this was described as “as kind of fine linen or thin cambric.” The thinner fabric suggested to me that her clothes were see through, which plays on the doubleness of Hero’s nature as hyper-sexualized and virginal. The blood on her dress show how much she is desired by men, but it also symbolizes that her dress has been tainted by the blood and therefore isn’t as innocent as she is perceived to be.