I was curious about the line:”in the time of man’s innocency, signifying unto us the mystical union that is betwixt Christ and his church.” It seems that “innocence” is often a gendered term, referring to chastity and virginity, so I was curious about the choice to refer to “man’s” innocency” here, and what that could signify. I also wonder about the phrase, “mystical union,” which seems to refer both a religious and metaphysical unification.
Separation of matrimony and spouse
I was surprised, in all of the readings, how separate the ideas of “matrimony” and the “spouse” were. This is perhaps most clear in Katherine Philips’s “A Married State.” She writes, “Thus you are freed from all the cares that do Attend on matrimony and a husband too” (Line 11). Both the marriage and the spouse each carry different challenges, and all of the authors are very clear to make this distinction. This is reinforced by all of the different purposes of marriage that are listed in “The Book of Common Prayer.” Marriage is not simply for the purpose of being with the one you love, and this is probably what leads to this great separation.
Hands in Marriage
It was really intriguing reading such a well known piece of prose and realizing how little I actually knew about it, in its entirety. Reading “The Form of Solemnization of Matrimony,” provided so much more context to the “vows” that are traditionally recited at weddings. After reading it, I saw the recitation much less vow’like, as I did previously, and more as contractual and instructional in nature. I was really surprised how much circumstantiation and justification that the prose provides, and how logistical/pragmatic the tone of the piece was despite its intention to be read aloud. More specifically, one element of “The Form of Solemnization of Matrimony” that I latched onto was the giving of the hands, despite the formality and pragmatism of the recitation. The giving of hands between a man and a woman seems like an intimate, emotional gesture but also stands as an example of the two physically becoming one. This is an idea that I think is worthy of delving deeper in to, and makes me question if the text stands as supportive of unification of two under marriage, or supportive of two individuals agreeing upon a new state of identity.
Impediments to Marriage
In the Book of Common Prayer, the speaker asks, “if either of you do know any impediment why ye may be lawfully joined together in matrimony, that ye confess it.” In doing so, the marriage/relationship is not a choice between two people, but open to the community for scrutiny. To me it seems like this could relate to our discussion of public/private life/acts and how marriage is regulate…if anyone else has any ideas on the subject!
Obedience
It was interesting to me the emphasis on obedience in these different texts, requiring obedience of both wives and subjects. The Book of Homilies made rebellion into a sacrilege, I assume because Cranmer was significantly worried about the threat of it. It seems then that the reason obedience was emphasized for wives may have also been for similar reasons–perhaps obedience for women was such a focus in part because men were worried what would happen if they were to rebel?
A Married State
I am intrigued by Katherine Philips’ “A Married State.” Philips gives women an option outside heterosexual love, it seems: “Therefore Madam, be advised by me/ Turn, turn apostate to love’s levity,/ Suppress wild nature if she dare rebel./ There’s no such thing as leading apes in hell.” She subverts the language of the Book of Homilies by invoking “rebel” and “hell,” which is an especially interesting tactic in a poem with this title. This poem reads like a whisper to another woman about how marriage isn’t all it’s imagined to be, which makes me wonder how it was circulated.
“Make Much of Time,” boys and girls
Both Shakespeare Robert Herrick’s poem “To the Virgins, to Make Much of Time” reminds me of Shakespeare’s hastening words, especially in Sonnet 1: ”
Shakespeare’s speaker addresses a man, urges him to have children, and in a chastising tone. Herrick’s speaker is more equivocating in its address. “The Virgins” only appear in the title; in the body of the poem, the speaker employs the second-person with “ye,” with rhyming platitudes that anyone might take to heart:
In the second stanza, the speaker’s perspective is cosmic: “The glorious lamp of heaven, the sun…” And the third stanza speaks broadly of “that age… when youth and blood are warmer.” Finally, the speaker seems to turn to “the virgins,” whom he cautions against chastity. But he does not–of course not!–suggest that they seize the day before they have married. The implication for a woman to share her youth and beauty requires a kind of flowery masking, as Herrick demonstrates on multiple levels in this poem. In urging this woman to share, the speaker’s worst must belie his own desire. But the man, “tender churl,” who does not beget heirs and propagate the race receives a bold, stern reminder of his responsibility: if he “mak’st waste in niggarding,” if he hoards his beauty and youth, then he will suffer, at least, in death (with no heirs).
To His Coy Mistress
Something I was thinking about for the reading this week was how the message of “To His Coy Mistress” parallels Shakespeare’s sonnets, especially the line, “The grave’s a fine and private place / But none, I think, do there, embrace.” Marvell seems to be urging the person he addresses in the poem to have sex with him because “they are young and alive” and there is time to be chaste when they are dead. This very much reminds me of the sentiments of the first 17 sonnets, which urge the young man to procreate.
Sexual Insecurity and “The Choice of Valentines”
In “The Choice of Valentines,” Nashe uses vivid descriptions and imagery to engage the male reader. While the poem’s plot and language make it very erotic and pleasing to his contemporary intended audience, he also uses humor to poke fun at the narrator and his inability to please Francis in the end. Nashe humorously addresses the insecurities of male sexuality, such as fear about one’s ability to satisfy a woman, and he combines this wit with explicitly erotic imagery and dialogue. I am curious as to how contemporary male readers would have received this poem as it is both seduces the reader and also forces him to face his sexual insecurities in face of a woman who is more sexually competent than he.
The Vine
In Robert Herrick’s poem, The Vine, the author recounts an erotic dream about his lover, Lucia. In the dream, his “mortal part” is “metamorphosed to a vine” that surrounds his lover. The vine reference is presumably phallic, and I was somewhat surprised by Herrick’s blatant sexual aggression. The repetition of the word “enthralled” to describe the vine’s effect on Lucia highlights this aggression, and she is described as a prisoner who “could not freely stir.” Although Herrick’s early tone is highly sexualized and almost disturbingly aggressive, his humor towards the end is a reminder that the poem is merely recounting a dream. His ability to poke fun at himself and his dream lightens the overall tone of the poem.
