Pornography as Invasion

Partially in response to the question in Prof Kitch’s email – how do the poems seduce the presumably male reader – I noticed a common thread throughout, and particularly in the works by Herrick and Marvell. The poems’ graphic natures do justify their categorization as pornography, but rather than the sexual acts appearing consensual, the poems in many cases use aggressive language, portraying the (presumably male) speaker as dominating and forceful. The speakers, particularly in “To His Coy Mistress” and “To the Virgins, to Make Much of Time,” don’t cajole the subjects into sexual acts as much as they attempt to force it on them, through scaremongering or other, more physical means. Likewise, “The Vine” takes on an invasive metaphor, describing the speaker’s penis as an invasive species of plant, making its way around the poem’s subject and then taking over, invading her very body.

This raises more general questions about pornography in the Renaissance age (and, indeed, how much these themes resonate even in contemporary pornography) – this porn, clearly produced for male readers, glorifies the masculine takeover of the female body, and encourages its reader to act on his lustful instincts regardless of the situation.

RE: Difference Between Naked and Nude

Hi Anais!

I really enjoyed reading your interpretation of Herrick’s poem. I read the poem as less focused on respecting Julia and more of creating an image of her from the male imagination. Particularly I noticed the metaphors of the cherry and the strawberry in cream. Both of these images suggest consumption. Thus, I read the poem with Julia, and her breasts in particular,  being an object for male enjoyment. I think that it is interesting to think about what I brought into my reading of the poem. I am certain that I read it expecting a certain amount of misogyny and I wonder if I would have had an interpretation closer to yours if I hadn’t begun with that bias.

Thanks!

Kacie

 

Difference between “Naked” and “Nude”?

While reading the poem “Upon the Nipples of Julia’s Breast”, I realized that yes there are certainly sexual undertones to Herrick’s fixation with this specific part of Julia, but I also noticed how he went about it in a way that was preserving her purity and innocence. For example,  he compares Julia’s nipples to cherries which can represent her sweetness in character and then her actual breast is a lily which can represent her purity. So I thought, if he wanted to focus so much on her purity and innocence, why choose to write a poem about her breasts? This question made me think about how when it comes to nudity, there is a difference between the words “Naked” and “Nude”. The word Naked usually has a more sexual connotation to it where someone is exposed in a way that they are vulnerable or indecent, usually seen in a negative light, as opposed to the word “Nude” which has a softer connotation to it where someone is seen as just uncovered, pure, and even comfortable. These differences in words that essentially mean the same thing is perhaps what Herrick is trying to address. In my opinion I feel as if he is trying to show in his writing that he can depict parts of a woman that are deemed sexual in nature and still show that she is being respected and emphasized for her character. He is also trying to show that sexuality is a natural thing that should not be deemed as shameful. Julia’s uncovered sexual organs do not mean that she is suddenly not pure, Herrick demonstrates that her exposing a natural part of herself can still indicate that she is remaining innocent and pure as well as her being able to show herself and be physical with a man that she is in love with. He also attempts to convey that physical love can actually be something that should be embraced because sexual feelings are present when two people are attracted to each other anyways and once welcomed, riches and prosperity can come such as the ones he describes when he compares Julia’s breasts to rubies and pearls.

Marlowe and Internalized Misogyny in Elizabethan England

Though I know Marlowe’s lines in Hero and Leander reflect the conventional social wisdom of his time, I found myself pretty bothered by some of the generalizations he made about women in this poem, and in his characterization of Hero herself. He presents Hero as a stereotypical “tease,” apparently always saying “no” when she means “yes” and relishing in the blood of her failed suitors that stains her skirt. When juxtaposed with Marlowe’s abhorrence of the rapacious actions of Jove, I found myself a bit confused about Marlowe’s view of the role of a woman’s consent in sexual relations, as it seemed impossible for Hero, and all women, to have her answer of “no” taken seriously when a man asked, or attempted to take, something of her body. Did anyone else get this vibe? And, if so, what does it say about women’s sexual agency in sixteenth century England?

Viola as Cesario (Twelfth Night) vs. Viola as Sebastian (She’s the Man)

I rewatched She’s The Man recently (in my opinion—still p good, but doesn’t hold up THAT well?), and I noticed that when Viola cross-dresses, she takes up Sebastian’s name, as opposed to taking on the new name of Cesario. The plot of She’s The Man actually demands that she takes on Sebastian’s name (because she wants to take his place at boarding school so she can play men’s soccer), but it struck me as a difference that actually significantly changes how we think about Viola’s new identity when she presents as a man. In Twelfth Night, the change to Cesario is the invention of a completely new male identity. In She’s The Man, she’s not inventing a new male identity so much as performing the identity of her brother. In this way, She’s The Man seems to sort of sanitize or un-trouble the gender complications of  Twelfth Night (which makes sense because it’s mainstream Hollywood). But I think this also speaks to the lack of resolution in the final act of Twelfth Night, because Olivia’s marriage to Sebastian does not actually resolve the fact that she has been in love with Cesario. Cesario and Sebastian are twins, but they are not perfect substitutions for one another. They have two different names, but still two different identities.

Re: Sarah’s “The Role of Comedy in Greenblatt”

One distinction I would make between comedy and the sonnets is the embodiment of performativity. As we (sorta) talked about in class, the sonnets are performances in that they can be thought of as dramatic monologues. But the performativity is more diffused—it exists either solely on the page, or in the aural experience of someone reading the poem out loud. An interesting thing happens there where the reader inherently and I think unintentionally takes up that performance—but that seems different to me than actually taking on a role for a play. For the comedies, the performance is an embodied performance. It is deliberately written to exist beyond the page. That doesn’t mean we should discount the performativity that exists only on the page—because there definitely are plays that are never performed, and perhaps never intended to be performed—but in the case of Shakespeare, I would choose to privilege the performance over the page.

The Role of Comedy in Greenblatt

At the end of Greenblatt’s essay, I was particularly interested in the emphasis he places on the role of Shakespeare’s comedies. He writes, “for Shakespeare friction is specifically associated with verbal wit; indeed at moments the plays seem to imply that erotic friction originates in the wantonness of language, and thus that the body itself is a tissue of metaphors or, conversely, that language is perfectly embodied” (89). All of these elements–minus the physical re-enactment on stage with real bodies–also seem present in Shakespeare’s sonnets, which I would argue are riddled with the same verbal wit. In a similar manner, the verbal wit in the sonnets also seems encoded in physical descriptions of the beloved or with gender (master-mistress). Specifically in this manner relating to verbal wit, I am wondering what differentiates comedy from the sonnet? Is the actual theatrical element of the comedy very important? Does the comedy allow more easily/readily for parody or social criticism?

Response to Sir Toby and Maria

Emma’s post raises the question of how Sir Toby and Maria’s coupling makes sense when other couplings necessitate an equal social status. I wonder how much of that has to do with Sir Toby’s gender, that perhaps marrying below one’s status as a woman is more problematic due to her limited agency in society. Especially for Olivia, who as a result of her father and brother’s death must fulfill both her role as a daughter and as the sole ruler of her family’s fortunes, marrying below her status would be especially problematic. Furthermore, because Sir Toby has relatively little power in the family’s fortunes, especially after Olivia marries, his actions could possibly be under far less scrutiny and therefore his marriage to Maria is less controversial.

Sir Toby and Maria

Greenblatt discusses how the revelation that Viola and Sebastian come from a noble family solves the issue of socially-mismatched couples so that social order is restored in end. Indeed, Malvolio, who sought to rise in the ranks by marrying Olivia, is cast aside and his aspirations ignored and refused. But Sir Toby and Maria marry even though the former is a nobleman and the latter, a servant. Even then, their marriage is only briefly touched upon when Fabian mentions it during his explanation of the Malvolio prank. Is their marriage acceptable because it’s not one of the main couples, or because Sir Toby does not behave like a noble, or because Maria somehow rises in status through her wit? It seems to me this marriage is the only one in which the two characters actually know each other for who they are, and it is the one that does not neatly fit into the social standards of the time.

Re Part 2: Alas, Poor Antonio

Hi Natalie and Rachel,

I also think that Antonio is a particularly interesting character. As we spoke about in class, his function in the play is not immediately apparent. I really like the reading of class in making Antonio’s declarations of love less threatening. I also think that its worth noting that Antonio is one of the most straightforward characters and thus does not engage in the  multiple layered language of the upper class characters. His declarations can be taken at face value, and do not attempt to create Greenblatt’s “friction.” In this way, I wonder if was easier to take Antonio’s declarations as homosocial bonding as opposed to homosexual because his dialogue (at least as I see it) never functions as the foreplay that others’ dialogue sometimes does.