Natalie I think you are raising an important point here. To me, the love Antonio expresses for Sebastian seems to me to be acceptable based on class-differences that appear throughout the play. Antonio as a person of a lower class than Sebastian adores him and the love of a servant for his master seems to be more acceptable. For example, nobody really questions Cesario’s love for Orsino because this is also a master-servant relationship.
Fiction and Friction / Shakespeare’s Globe
One of the things that stuck out to me from Greenblatt’s article was his idea that most of the transformations and exchanges in Twelfth Night show how “men love women precisely as representations, a love the original performances of these plays literalized in the person of the boy actor” (93). With the Globe performance of Twelfth Night, we got a sense of how Renaissance theater used the body as a way to both reveal and trouble gender and sexuality; how women “pass through the state of being men in order to become women…. Shakespearean women are in this sense the representation of Shakespearean men” (92). In order for a woman to really be a woman, she must have first been “legitimized” as a man.
Re: the word “element”
Hi Rachel,
I thought your point about this word was really interesting, especially considering the role that the physical elements (the weather/natural forces) play in Twelfth Night; a storm is the catalyst for the plot, when Viola and Sebastian are stranded, while Feste concludes the play with a song about “the wind and the rain.” Fittingly with the consciously-theatrical nature of this play, Feste references how “A great while ago the world begun, / With hey, ho, the wind and the rain,” — reminding the audience that the world of Twelfth Night began with a storm. I’m curious about the connection between performance/disguising your “element” and the natural elements, or if there is even one?
Thought from my response paper
The moments we get to know Viola best occur when her double and single gender identities cause friction. She fumbles when speaking about love to Orsino, her object of desire, and states: “I am all the daughters of my father’s house, / And all the brothers too” (2.4.120-1). In attempting to cover up her previous statement, concerning her knowledge about female love, she thus invokes her doubled identity. Several scenes later, Viola invokes her identity again, to rebut Olivia’s love; Viola states: “I am not what I am” (3.1.138). Viola implies here that she is not a man, but a woman, and encompasses a single gender. The moments where Viola must speak for her identity reveal that it is shaped by both Duval’s notions of double and single gender identities, and thus illustrates Greenblatt’s argument that identity forms at the boundaries between categories.
Alas, Poor Antonio
In his piece “Fiction and Friction,” Greenblatt mentions Antonio’s passion for Sebastian in passing several times, but he does not spend a particularly long time dwelling on this relationship – arguably the most explicit example of homosexual desire in Twelfth Night. I find it interesting that Antonio is so bold as to declare his love for Sebastian in no uncertain terms, not only to Sebastian himself but also to others – including officers who have come to arrest him for other crimes – especially considering the sentences imposed on Marin le Marcis and his lover during the same time period. In view of the fact that le Marcis and le Febvre were condemned to horrible punishments and grisly deaths for engaging in homosexual behavior, how can Antonio so brazenly declare his homosexual love in such public spaces? Is it a sex-based determination, since le Marcis and le Febvre were both women and Antonio and Sebastian are both men? As Greenblatt points out, Shakespeare frequently makes self-reflexive references to the fact that all female parts in his comedies were being played by men, but Antonio’s love is not an object of levity or humor but one of serious passion, and he is ultimately “left out in the cold” but not threatened with bodily harm (Greenblatt 93). I find it difficult to reconcile such differing reactions to the presence of homosexual love and relations in Elizabethan England. Any ideas?
authenticity and love
Hey Emily,
I think your remark on authenticity and representation on the blog also connects to our discussion in class today about who gets to experience fulfilling love. Is authentic love that which is pursued, as Olivia pursues–though not the right lover? Is it encompassed in creative language, as Viola can express, rather than in the tired language that Orsino uses? Can it be simply happened upon, as Sebastian walks into the love plot and ends up with Olivia? Is there one kind of authentic love that can be derived from all of the intersecting love plots? Just as we cannot quite know who everyone really is, we also cannot know the true nature of the love that drives the play.
The word “element”
I am curious about the word “element” that appears so many times throughout the play. For example, the Fool particularly calls attention to this word in 3.1 where he says “who you are and what you would are out of my welkin–I might say ‘element,’ but the word is overworn” (3.1.56-58). My guess is that this has to do with people’s internal natures and the fact that it is so difficult to see a person’s actual “element” throughout the play–the gender bending but also the numerous other disguises people take on throughout the scenes.
Reply to Borrowed Language
Hi Natalie!
I was also struck by the use of borrowed language, but also how it often revealed itself as language slippage. More specifically the use of French and how miscommunication between two characters was represented throughout the play. I feel like the use of French is making a crack at the European aristocratic, and may be catering towards its audience member and their sense of humor. However I feel like this is more clearly communicated when watching the performance than when it sneaks its way into moments in the written play. When two characters miscommunicate because of multiple definitions or different uses of the same word, it seems to o spark a long exchange between the two, and that they are unable to move on from it. It often leads to humour but I’m wondering what it’s saying now broadly about reading Shakespeare’s work and how we analyze it. Perhaps he is suggesting that even if you can’t reconcile that there is more than one way to read his writing style and word choice, appreciate that ambiguity.
RE: Quote On Greatness
Hi Tully!
I was also interested in the origins of the quote “Some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some / have greatness thrust upon ’em” (2.5.136-37). I have only ever heard this quote being used in the utmost sincerity, so it was interesting to learn that it’s original context was as a practical joke. These lines are an inflation of Malvolio’s dreams and desires, not something that Marie actually believes. The underlying humor of these lines are further emphasized when Malvolio repeats them to Olivia with pompous sincerity and (in the production at least) emphasis on the sexuality of the lines (3.4). All of this is to say that I was surprised that these lines were originally intended ironically, given how they now stand as inspiration for class mobility.
on “authenticity”…
Representation, as we have discussed in class, is a central theme in Twelfth Night (and certainly in Shakespeare’s sonnets as well). Viola masquerades as a man and Olivia masques herself. The fool qualifies his title as Olivia’s “corruptor of words,” always speaking aslant of meaning, playing with multiplicities, paradoxical, ironic, or taboo, putting language itself to task, doing away with the “over-worn”; And Viola says that the fool is more clever for it: “For folly that he wisely shows is fit, / But wise men, folly-fall’n, quite taint their wit” (3.1.66-7). This play does not just represent representation. It demonstrates how representation might convey reticence and virtuousness in Olivia, sharpness and laudable skill in the fool, deceit on Viola’s part that creates a messy love triangle situation, which, she says at one point, she cannot possibly untangle. Representation and “seeming” in Twelfth Night (if we can say that representation and seeming are the same… ?), are also themselves a matter of interpretation, as we learn in Viola and Olivia’s comedic/cringe-y repartee in Act 3 scene 2. Viola says, “[I think] you do think you are not what you are.” Olivia replies, “If I think so, I think the same of you.” Viola: “Then think you right, I am not what I am. Olivia: “I would you were as I would have you be.” Viola: “Would it be better, madam, than I am?” Olivia and Viola are not, of course, referring to the same sorts of misrepresentation, since Olivia does not know Viola is actually a woman. But their dialogue is so synchronized, so syntactically and tonally matched, that the reader/spectator might lose the plot here. What is the veiled truth? Who is what? Shakespeare’s characters often ask, “what are you?” as opposed to our familiar “who”… So, is there any “authentic” self? What is “authentic”? Can’t representation–especially self-presentation–be authentic? Maybe today, but perhaps not in Elizabethan England.
