I would like to talk about how Cather further develops and dissolves three relationships in this section of reading.

The first is the complicated relationship that is never meant to be between Marie and Emil highlighted in chapter VIII.  I wonder about the symbolism of the trees in this section, especially the cherries and the white mulberry, as they discuss if trees bring good or bad luck.

The second is the familial relationship between Alexandra and her brothers developed in chapter X.  Their argument over Carl and Alexandra highlights the tension over their property and their sexist perceptions of who deserves the right to it.

Finally in chapter XII the termination of the potential relationship between Carl and Alexandra highlights the intersection of societal norms, wealth and love.